Home > Rights > Legal Aid Cuts Make Fighting Disputes More Expensive

Legal Aid Cuts Make Fighting Disputes More Expensive

By: Sarah Clark (ILEX) - Updated: 17 Jan 2021 | comments*Discuss
Neighbour Dispute Legal Aid Ministry Of

Changes to the legal aid system could mean it becomes more difficult for people to pursue a claim against a problem neighbour in the future. In late 2010, it was announced that the income for people who provide legal aid for civil cases could be cut by up to £154m. This will severely restrict the amount of money available to people who needed help pursuing cases such as boundary disputes.

A consultation paper, published in November 2010, outlined proposals that would see over half a million civil cases being denied legal aid (and not just neighbourhood disputes, but divorce and family matters were also likely to be affected). The court fees will be cut by 10%, but as most people who become involved in legal action will be able to tell you, it’s not the court fees that are the problem, it’s the ever-escalating solicitor’s costs.

Legal aid firms are likely to lose between £144m and £154m per year due to the cuts, which are being proposed to save the ministry of Justice around £350m by 2014/15.

What if You Can’t Afford Legal Costs?

If you have a dispute that you might be Considering Taking Legal Action, the advice from the Ministry of Justice is to try alternative dispute resolutions first. The Ministry has also suggested that funding for cases that would have been supported by legal aid in the past could be taken from the interest generated from solicitors’ client accounts, or even a new ‘supplementary’ legal aid scheme, where money is taken out of the damages won by successful claimants who were given legal aid to fight their claims.

If you need advice and can’t afford a solicitor, the alternative dispute resolution services on offer include other formal ways to resolve disputes such as:

  • Mediation
  • Expert Determination
  • RICS Neighbour Disputes Service
Mediation is the only method that leaves the decision-making totally down to the people involved. The mediator is simply a facilitator and doesn’t make any decisions. Anyone you choose to be a mediator should have a background in property law.

An expert determination is a contractually binding decision which should be carried out by an expert who will thoroughly analyse all of the documentary and the physical evidence, then draw conclusions based upon his analysis of the evidence.

The RICS Neighbour Disputes Service is a part-expert determination and part-mediation service for boundary disputes, which costs over £3,000, and can be paid between the parties or by just one. A chartered surveyor has to be appointed jointly and there are no solicitors involved, keeping the costs down. It seems a lot of money, but to put it into perspective, taking this sort of case to the county court can easily cost in excess of £20,000.

The Future of Neighbour Disputes?

The director of the Legal Action Group said that he believed the cuts meant that the government was, in effect, walking away from ‘ordinary members of the public’, and they were all about making quick savings, which would devastate civil legal aid services without causing too much political damage.

There are possibilities for more no-win no-fee personal injury style litigation for boundary disputes or similar cases, but these tend to be expensive and time consuming, and don’t follow the same guidelines as personal injury claims. So it’s hard to imagine that this style of litigation will be adopted for protracted neighbourhood disputes.

The Ministry is reviewing civil litigation as a whole, including looking at the no-win, no-fee (or conditional fee) agreements, and is already discussing abolishing the practice of getting the fees and insurance premiums recovered from losing parties in civil actions, and instead allowing legal fees to be paid out of the winning party’s damages. It’s likely that taking any neighbour-related case to litigation will become more difficult and certainly more expensive in the future, so watch this space for updates.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
[Add a Comment]
A Neighbor moved in approx 6 years ago, since then she consistently stalked, harassed, bullied, and even attacked me. if I go out she films and photographs me. over the years I have called the police to be faced with them coming to my house saying "what have you done to upset your neighbor"At the times I defended myself, I was made out the "bad guy" I never instigated anything. she even shot at me with a gon, all cought on my sons drone. but was not acceptable as evidence as she said she was "shooting birds" but recently in a post she admitted to being a good shot and having shot at me, but bragged how good a shot she was that she actually missed on purpose. I have tried the local council again to noa vail. the "ASBA" team as I call them, spoke to her several times and "advised her not to post on social media" yet today I find 6 years down the line she is posting to no less than 16 villages in our area around us, slating to say we are drug dealers, animal abusers paedophiles scammers, horse abusers. the list goes on and on. I am nearly 60 (will be next week) I actually love animals, dont own a horse! DETEST drugs. anyone and everyone that knows me would know its not me, so perhaps its another neighbour on the other side she is aiming at? either way she is tarring the entire neighbourhood as paedophiles, stalkers, harasser's animal abusers, thieves, the list goes on. It has driven me indoors, to not have a life and to be suicidal as there is no hope and no help out there! and I have no money. and no I cant sell up and leave, not at my age, condition as I have no family or anyone to help. I am totally alone.
skiandu - 17-Jan-21 @ 6:12 PM
Hello I live in a council flat and the neighbours in the flat below who moved in 3 years ago have complained about alleged noise from my flat ever since they moved in. They have shouted out the window in the middle of the night distressing us and also other neighbours in the building and they have also banged and shouted through my door many times. I complained to the council about this unreasonable behaviour and the neighbours downstairs were told to stop this behaviour by the housing officers for the building.The housing officers visited my flat and took pictures of my floorring. The housing officers also told my neighbours to get an independent witness to their flat from the council to witness the noise. Which they never did. Now we have 2 new housing officers so the whole noise dispute has started up again from scratch, much to my anguish and distress. These 2 new housing officers seem to be on the side of the neighbours who are complaining, although they insist they are neutral. The new housing officers demanded that I an come into a meeting with them to discuss the neighbours complaints against me, and they asked me what I think should be done. They suggested mediation but I said I dint think that would solve this problem as my neighbours will not listen to me, when I try to explain that I am not making noise. Due to their abusive and aggressive behaviour towards me banging on my door and shouting through their window I really dont want to meet with them or have anything to do with them. The 2 housing officers demanded entry into my flat to look at the flooring (again) and I told them I am having surgery and really need to have some peace and not be harrassed. Now we have the virus pandemic so I dont have to let these housing officers into my flat but they are phoning me, and I dont want to answer their calls, and also they cant leave messages on my phone as my phone is set up so I dont get voice mail. I feel that I ma being victimised and harrassed by my neighbours and also by the council housing officers. What are my rights in this situation?
baileyb - 31-Mar-20 @ 2:10 PM
Sjalia - Your Question:
For the past 2yrs the flat above have been so noisy. I've let it pass as much as I can as they have 3 young kids. However I'm now knocking on their door most nights due to the adults shouting at each other, banging around till 2am then up at 7am due to their kids. I've had fly infestation as they don't clean up. Washing machine on at 5am etc. They say they aren't making noise the council don't reply back to me. At breaking point as I to have a child and he's only getting half a nights sleep regularly. Anything else I can do?

Our Response:
Which council department have you complained to? You need to be speaking to environmental health. They may ask you to keep a diary of the noises, so it might be worth persevering and doing this before complaining again. They have a duty to respond to all questions and complaints so if you do not get a response, make a complaint to the local government ombudsman
ProblemNeighbours - 14-Aug-18 @ 2:16 PM
For the past 2yrs the flat above have been so noisy. I've let it pass as much as I can as they have 3 young kids. However I'm now knocking on their door most nights due to the adults shouting at each other, banging around till 2am then up at 7am due to their kids. I've had fly infestation as they don't clean up. Washing machine on at 5am etc. They say they aren't making noise the council don't reply back to me. At breaking point as I to have a child and he's only getting half a nights sleep regularly. Anything else I can do?
Sjalia - 2-Aug-18 @ 8:48 AM
@alpha1. We have a new article about the antisocial behaviour act. Take a look here.
ProblemNeighbours - 27-Aug-14 @ 11:16 AM
try asking the council to issue an asbo agaist the people concerned
alpha1 - 27-Aug-14 @ 9:46 AM
Moved into upstairs flat beginning June. Lady living alone on ground floor is one of those who smiles to your face, but she's done the following behaviours since I moved in:1. Pouncing on me soon as I leave, or return home, normally it will be a complaint, but she says it with a smile all the time, the complaints are unreasonable (she complained that my little fan in my bedroom was a noise disturbance to her, claiming it kept her up all night, and that when I use my stairs it is 'thunderously' loud and gives her a migraine) I hardly use my stairs2. Deliberately leaving her front door open when my young son is over, with her Staffordshire terrier right there, unleashed and barking, then later going on about how vicious her dog is, how he would kill another dog if it came into the house3. Causing late night noises, most recently outside by my front door, this was at midnight, and it scared me. I realised it was her because next day she told me it was her, laughing. Gardening or hammering just outside my window until 11pm. Allowing her dog to constantly bark and growl outside my window all day long.4. I am supposed to have half the back garden, by contract. But she has taken over the garden. I cannot access it because of the aggressive dog.5. She was on and on about me putting in carpets, claiming the noise without carpet was bothering her. I finally got the money to put in cheap carpet. When the carpet van arrived, she phoned the company to complain they were 'blocking her drive,' when they weren't. She then moaned that it was still noisy because it didn't have underlay. I am hardly home.6. Buzzing me regularly just as I sit down to dinner, within minutes of me getting home.She has lived in her flat for years and has loads of family nearby. So I am scared to complain. Scared of retaliation. What do I do??? Please any advice appreciated. Oh, and before I signed the contract to move in, she tried to put me off, claiming that the heating was 'astronomical' and that the area had a bad stench often from the sewage. I feel she is not happy I am here, and it's because I am not from the UK, I think this is about that, cause Ive done nothing to cause her to dislike me Ive been nothing but polite
dani - 3-Jul-13 @ 8:44 PM
my next door neighbours and i had an altercation about a year ago it has come to a head this week and since then i have had verbal abuse from the family everytime we come in contact this cant be avoided as we share a common path what are my options to stop this it is making me very anxious,my husband andi are pensioners not that makes a lot of difference but we could do without the harrasment.thank you
rothesay - 3-Jul-13 @ 2:24 PM
my neighbour harassing my child. my child age is 11 years old. please tell me what action taken me for my neighbour.
SANGITA - 17-Nov-12 @ 7:19 AM
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice...
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
Enter word:
Latest Comments